Upper James

START ORDER

START ORDER

TAKE OUT

CALL: 905-389-6696

Hours

Sun - Wed: 11:30 am to 11 pm
Thur: 11:30 am to 12 am
Fri - Sat: 11:30 am to 1 am

Dinner Menu

Menu Options

Dietary Options

Shareables

Guacamole & Chips

$14.85

Edamame

$10.85

Fried Calamari

$19.65

3 Cheese Dip

$18.65

Fried Pickles

$13.00

Roasted Garlic Chicken Rolls

$18.85

Beef Nachos

$28.85

Chicken 28.85 / Vegetarian 25.85

Add fresh guacamole 3

Chicken Quesadilla

$18.35

Add fresh guacamole 3

Turtle Wings

$18.85

Big Bang Shrimp

$18.85

Try it Buffalo style in our signature NY Butter Sauce®

Whipped Feta

$15.85

Gyoza Dumplings

$13.00

Soups & Salads

Beef Barley Soup

$9.65

Seasonal Soup

Market Price

French Onion Soup

$11.00

Soup & Salad

$17.35

Garlic Caesar

$12.95

Half 9.95

Fresh Greens

$12.95

Half 9.95

Greek

$13.95

Half 10.95

Thai Chicken

$24.35

Asian greens, carrots, snow peas, red pepper, edamame, mango, peanut satay, red cabbage, crispy wontons, peanuts, sesame dressing

Blackened Chicken & Goat Cheese

$24.35

Greens, carrots, cucumber, tomato, radish, dried cranberries, hemp hearts, balsamic vinaigrette

Handhelds

All Handhelds & Burgers served with choice of Fries, Beef Barley Soup, Seasonal Soup, Fresh Greens, or Garlic Caesar Salad.
Add Gravy 2 / Greek Salad, Sweet Potato Fries, or Onion Rings 3

BLACKENED BASA TACO

$21.85

Pineapple mango salsa, guacamole, sweet & spicy aioli

California Turkey Sandwich

$23.85

Bacon, cheddar, tomato, lettuce, cucumber, roasted garlic aioli, multigrain bread

Add avocado 3

Blackened Chicken on Naan

$22.65

Tomato, goat cheese, lettuce, red onion, chimichurri, mayo

French Dip

$23.65

Roasted, shaved top sirloin, horseradish dijonnaise, au jus, French baguette

Add mushrooms & Swiss cheese 3

Add sautéed onions, peppers & jalapeño havarti 3

Turkey & Goat Cheese on Naan

$21.85

Roasted red peppers, tomato, arugula, roasted garlic aioli

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$21.85

Chicken tenders, tomato, lettuce, cheddar, ranch, choice of sauce

Nashville Chicken Sandwich

$21.85

Fried chicken breast, pickles, lettuce, mayo, Nashville sauce, ACE® Bakery bun

Burgers

Our burgers are made from a blend of fresh never frozen Canadian brisket, chuck & prime rib for a rich flavour.

The Classic

$20.85

Tomato, lettuce, red onion, pickles, mayo

Add cheddar 2

Bacon & Cheddar

$22.85

Onion straws, tomato, lettuce, red onion, pickles, mayo

Hell-of-a-Burger

$22.85

Bacon, jalapeño, jalapeño havarti, tomato, lettuce, red onion, house-made pimento cheese

Garden

$23.00

Beyond Meat® burger, guacamole, arugula, tomato, turmeric mayo, feta

Muskoka

$23.85

Peameal bacon glazed with signature NY Butter Sauce®, cheddar, tomato, lettuce, pickled red onion, mayo

Add a sunny-side-up egg 2

Bison

$27.85

Gruyère baby arugula, garlic aioli, portabella & cremini mushrooms sautéed in garlic, thyme, sesame oil, & soy sauce

Wings & Fingers

Choice of sauce, dusted or regular, barbied or convected.
Sauces: Mild, Medium, Hot, signature NY Butter Sauce®, Original BBQ, Honey Garlic, Nashville, Red Thai Chili, Ghost Pepper, Baton Rouge, Cajun Wet, Cajun Dry, Honey Sriracha, Lemon Pepper

Chicken Wings

$18.85

Fryers or Roasters 1 lb

2 lb 37.65

Choice of sauce, dusted or regular, barbied or convected

Big Wing Dinner: Roasters or fryers with fries 22.35

Chicken Fingers

$20.00

Fries, coleslaw, plum sauce

Classic Buffalo Fingers: Tossed in your choice of sauce

Bowls

Add to any bowl: goat cheese or feta 3 / chicken 7 / shrimp 8 / steak or salmon 11

Power Bowl

$21.85

Quinoa, heritage blend, sweet potato, avocado, beets, edamame, cucumber, tomato, chickpeas, hemp hearts, sweet onion vinaigrette, mint yogurt drizzle

Yellow Coconut Curry

$26.00

Chicken, peppers, onion, carrots, bok choy, celery, snow peas, coconut rice, peanuts, cilantro, black sesame seeds

Vegetarian 25 / Shrimp 27

Tuna Poke

$26.00

Marinated Ahi Tuna, brown rice, mango, edamame, cucumber, avocado, pickled carrots, radish, sesame seeds, green onion, sriracha aioli

Kung Pao

$23.85

Chicken, stir fried vegetables, red Thai chili, chow mein noodles, garlic ginger soy sauce

Vegetarian 21.85

Shrimp 24.85

Burger Bowl

$23.35

Brisket chuck prime rib patty, cheddar, bacon, hard boiled egg, pickled red onion, sweet potato, pickles, tomatoes, avocado, house lettuce mix, white balsamic

Steak & Lobster

We use the highest quality, fresh, Prime Grade & Certified Angus Beef® steaks that are hand-selected for generous marbling. Aged for a minimum of 45 days for the most desirable flavour and tenderness.

Prime Top Sirloin 8oz

$34.85

Lobster tail 21.95

Shrimp in garlic white wine cream sauce 9

Peppercorns, white wine, brandy, cream 6

California Cut New York Striploin 10oz

$46.85

Lobster tail 21.95

Shrimp in garlic white wine cream sauce 9

Peppercorns, white wine, brandy, cream 6

Tenderloin 7oz

$49.85

Lobster tail 21.95

Shrimp in garlic white wine cream sauce 9

Peppercorns, white wine, brandy, cream 6

Ribeye 14oz

$49.85

Lobster tail 21.95

Shrimp in garlic white wine cream sauce 9

Peppercorns, white wine, brandy, cream 6

Tuscan Steak Sandwich

$28.00

Certified Angus Beef® top sirloin 5oz, Swiss cheese, mushrooms, oven roasted tomatoes, arugula, herbed focaccia. Served with your choice of side

Lobster Ravioli

$30.00

Lobster stuffed ravioli, lobster cream sauce, lobster pieces, peas

Lobster Tail Dinner

$54.00

Two lobster tails baked or fried, Yukon mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables, lobster cream sauce

Mains

New York Chicken Dinner

$27.00

Fried chicken breast tossed in signature NY Butter Sauce®, tomato, ranch dressing, Yukon mashed potatoes, vegetables

Chicken Fajitas

$30.00

Sautéed peppers & onion, Spanish rice, cheddar, lettuce, salsa, sour cream

Vegetarian 25.35 / Add fresh guacamole 3

Bison Meatloaf

$30.00

Bacon, demi-glace, onion straws, Yukon mashed potatoes, vegetables

Blackened Chicken

$29.65

Creamy garlic fettuccine alfredo, parmesan reggiano, cajun garlic butter, vegetables

Chicken Parmesan

$28.00

Pomodoro sauce, mozzarella, pappardelle, tomato pesto cream sauce

Add garlic toast 2 / with cheese 3

4 Cheese Cajun Chicken Penne

$27.00

Blackened chicken, spinach, roasted red peppers, Creole alfredo, cheddar, mozzarella, feta, asiago

Add garlic toast 2 / with cheese 3

Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo

$24.85

Creamy garlic alfredo, parmesan reggiano

Shrimp 25.85 / Add garlic toast 2 / with cheese 3

Try it blackened in our cajun spice.

Seafood Fettuccine

$27.85

Shrimp, salmon, roasted red peppers, sundried tomato, snow peas, green onion, white wine parmesan cream sauce

Add garlic toast 2 / with cheese 3

Fish & Chips

$21.00

Haddock, Rickard’s Red® beer batter, fries, coleslaw, tartar sauce

2 pcs 27

Blackened Basa

$27.85

Lobster mashed potatoes, vegetables, chimichurri, guacamole

Pineapple Mango Salmon

$31.85

Coconut rice, vegetables, pineapple mango salsa

Try it blackened in our cajun spice.

Back Ribs

Sauces: Original, Sweet Red BBQ, Honey Garlic, Forty Creek®

Half Rack

$30.00

Choice of sauce, fries, coleslaw

Full Rack

$38.00

Choice of sauce, fries, coleslaw

Rib & Wing

$34.85

Half rack of ribs, four roaster wings, choice of sauce, fries, coleslaw

Handcrafted Cocktails

Spice Island Smash

$12.95

Captain Morgan® Spiced rum, pineapple juice, freshly squeezed lemon juice, sliced jalapeño, cherry syrup, soda water (1oz)

Strawberry Rose Spritz

$12.95

Tanqueray® Rangpur gin, strawberry syrup, freshly squeezed lime juice, pineapple juice, strawberries, soda water (1.5 oz)

Peach Aperol Spritz

$15.85

Cottage Springs Peach vodka, Aperol, Serenissima Prosecco, peach juice, peach slices, mint, soda water (5 oz)

Minted Melon

$14.95

Ciroc® Watermelon vodka, freshly squeezed lime juice, cane syrup, watermelon, mint, soda water (1.5 oz)

Spicy Mango Margarita

$15.85

Don Julio® Blanco tequila, spicy mango purée, freshly squeezed lime juice, agave syrup (1 oz)

Blood Orange Margarita

$15.85

Jose Cuervo® Silver tequila, Tanqueray® Flor de Sevilla gin, blood orange purée, freshly squeezed lime juice, agave syrup (1.5 oz)

Upgrade to Don Julio® Blanco tequila 3.95

Cottage Classics

Poolside Peach Fizz

$12.95

Crown Royal® Peach whisky, freshly squeezed lemon juice, orange juice, house-made honey syrup, ginger ale (1 oz)

Raspberry Mojito

$11.45

Smirnoff® Raspberry vodka, sweet & sour, raspberries, mint, soda water (1 oz)

Pitcher (4 oz) 31.95

Muskoka Mule

$12.25

Smirnoff® vodka, freshly squeezed lime juice, ginger beer (1.5 oz)

Perfect Margarita

$14.95

Don Julio® Blanco tequila, sweet & sour, orange juice, agave syrup (1 oz)

Add .5 oz Grand Marnier® 2.99

Sunkissed Sangria

$13.95

Crown Royal® Peach whisky, Beringer White Zinfandel, raspberries, peach, cranberry & orange juice, sweet & sour, soda water (4 oz)

Pitcher (16 oz) 41.95

The Classic Caesar

$11.85

Smirnoff® vodka, Clamato, spices, garnished with a pepperette, Monterey Jack cheese & dill pickle (1 oz)

Alcohol-Free Cocktails

Tropical Breeze

$7.45

Pineapple juice, passion fruit & mango syrup, soda water

Raspberry Peach Fizz

$7.45

Freshly squeezed lemon juice, peach & raspberry syrup, soda water

Watermelon Refresher

$7.45

Watermelon & mint syrup, mint, soda water

Grapefruit Mango Smash

$7.45

Freshly squeezed lemon juice, mango & grapefruit syrup, mango, soda water

Draught Beer

Turtle size your draught for $1.75 (Add 5 oz to your draught)

MadrÍ Excepcional (16oz)

$8.75

MOLSON CANADIAN (18oz)

$8.85

29.50 (60 oz)

COORS LIGHT (18oz)

$8.85

29.50 (60 oz)

Coors Original (18oz)

$9.75

31.25 (60 oz)

CREEMORE SPRINGS PREMIUM LAGER (18oz)

$9.75

31.25 (60 oz)

RICKARD'S RED (18oz)

$9.75

31.25 (60 oz)

BLUE MOON BELGIAN-STYLE WHEAT ALE (18oz)

$9.75

31.25 (60 oz)

HOP VALLEY BUBBLE STASH IPA (18oz)

$9.75

31.25 (60 oz)

HEINEKEN (18oz)

$10.95

36.50 (60 oz)

GUINNESS (18oz)

$10.95

Bottles & Cans

COORS LIGHT (341 ml)

$7.85

MOLSON CANADIAN (341 ml)

$7.85

Amstel Ultra (355ml)

$8.25

Miller Lite (341 ml)

$8.85

Miller High Life (355 ml)

$8.85

Miller Genuine Draft (355 ml)

$8.85

MOLSON Ultra (355 ml)

$8.85

SOL (330 ml)

$8.85

HEINEKEN (330 ml)

$9.35

Ciders & Coolers

Coors Seltzers (473 ml)

$9.45

Ask your server for details

Vizzy Seltzers (473 ml)

$9.45

Ask your server for details

Simply Spiked Lemonade (355 ml)

$8.95

Ask your server for details

STRONGBOW Cider (440 ml)

$9.45

COTTAGE SPRINGS RASPBERRY LEMONADE (12 oz on tap)

$8.50

Cottage Springs Vodka Soda (355 ml)

$8.95

Ask your server for details

Sparkling Wines & Rosés

SERENISSIMA PROSECCO (200 ml)

$17.00

Veneto, Italy

52 (750 ml)

SPARKLING CUVÉE ROSÉ (750 ml)

$57.00

Oyster Bay, New Zealand

WHITE ZINFANDEL (5 oz)

$7.99

Beringer, California

11.99 (8 oz), 14.49 (10 oz), 34 (750 ml)

ROSÉ (5 oz)

$12.99

Oyster Bay, New Zealand

16.99 (8 oz), 19.49 (10 oz), 49 (750 ml)

White Wines

CHARDONNAY (5 oz)

$9.49

Peller Estates, Niagara, VQA

13.49 (8 oz), 15.99 (10 oz)

RIESLING (5 oz)

$9.99

Deinhard Green Label, Germany

13.99 (8 oz), 16.49 (10 oz), 40 (750 ml)

PINOT GRIGIO (5 oz)

$9.99

Wayne Gretzky, Niagara, VQA

13.99 (8 oz), 16.49 (10 oz), 40 (750 ml)

PINOT GRIGIO (5 oz)

$11.29

Matto, Italy

15.29 (8 oz), 17.79 (10 oz), 44 (750 ml)

SAUVIGNON BLANC (5 oz)

$11.99

Matua Valley, New Zealand

15.99 (8 oz), 18.49 (10 oz), 46 (750 ml)

CHARDONNAY (5 oz)

$12.49

Josh Cellars, California

16.49 (8 oz), 18.99 (10 oz), 48 (750 ml)

CHARDONNAY (5 oz)

$12.99

Oyster Bay, New Zealand

16.99 (8 oz), 19.49 (10 oz), 49 (750 ml)

Red Wines

Cabernet Merlot (5 oz)

$9.49

Peller Estates, Niagara, VQA

13.49 (8 oz), 15.99 (10 oz)

Cabernet Sauvignon (5 oz)

$10.49

Woodbridge by Robert Mondavi, California

14.49 (8 oz), 16.99 (10 oz), 44 (750 ml)

Shiraz (5 oz)

$10.49

Wolf Blass Yellow Label, Australia

14.49 (8 oz), 16.99 (10 oz), 44 (750 ml)

Malbec (5 oz)

$10.99

Canciller Reserva, Argentina

14.99 (8 oz), 17.49 (10 oz), 45 (750 ml)

Merlot (5 oz)

$10.99

Black Oak, California

14.99 (8 oz), 17.49 (10 oz), 45 (750 ml)

Pinot Noir (5 oz)

$10.99

Trius, Niagara, VQA

14.99 (8 oz), 17.49 (10 oz), 45 (750 ml)

Cabernet Sauvignon (5 oz)

$12.99

Josh Cellars, California

16.99 (8 oz), 19.49 (10 oz), 50 (750 ml)

Cabernet Sauvignon (5 oz)

$12.99

Bonanza, California

16.99 (8 oz), 19.49 (10 oz), 50 (750 ml)

Organic Cabernet Sauvignon (5 oz)

$13.99

Bonterra, California

17.99 (8 oz), 20.49 (10 oz), 51 (750 ml)

Reserve White Wines

Pinot Grigio (750 ml)

$55.00

Vin Di Vore, Italy

Sancerre Blanc (750 ml)

$60.00

Daniel Chotard, France

Chablis (750 ml)

$65.00

La Manufacture, France

Reserve Red Wines

Available at select locations

Barolo (750ml)

$90.00

Casina Bric, Italy

Cabernet Sauvignon (750 ml)

$95.00

Beringer Knights Valley, California

Brunello Di Montalcino (750ml)

$120.00

Collemattoni, Italy

FRACASTORO RISERVA AMARONE (750ml)

$125.00

Valpolicella, Italy

Mains

Chicken Fingers or Buffalo Fingers

$12.99

Mini Burger

$11.49

Add cheese .99

Grilled Chicken

$12.49

Wings

$12.49

Grilled Steak

$13.49

Cheese Pizza

$11.49

With pepperoni 12.49

Beef Tacos

$12.49

Grilled Cheese Fingers

$11.49

Turtle Shell Pasta

Does not include seasoned fries

With Tomato Sauce 10.49

With Cheese 11.49

With Meatballs 12.49

Desserts

Kids Brownie

$3.99

Kids Sundae

$3.99

Desserts

Lake Rosseau Butter Tart

$11.49

Fresh, flaky pastry with a deliciously rich filling of pure butter & sweet brown sugar

Fire ’n Ice

$11.49

Vanilla ice cream rolled in a cinnamon crust, fried & topped with whipped cream, caramel & chocolate sauce

Turtle Pie

$12.49

Heavenly brownie with walnuts & chocolate flakes covered with a layer of caramel & chocolate mousse

Skor® Brownie Obsession

$15.99

Our warm classic fudge brownie toppied with vanilla ice cream, chocolate & caramel sauce, SKOR® pieces, whipped cream

Sticky Toffee Pudding

$12.99

Layers of lightly spiced sponge cake glazed with whipped cream & a rich buttery golden toffee sauce, topped with vanilla ice cream & caramel drizzle

Turtle Jack’s

Hours

DIRECTIONS

Contact

MENUS

Shareables

Guacamole & Chips

$14.85

Edamame

$10.85

Fried Calamari

$19.65

3 Cheese Dip

$18.65

Fried Pickles

$13.00

Roasted Garlic Chicken Rolls

$18.85

Beef Nachos

$28.85

Chicken Quesadilla

$18.35

Turtle Wings

$18.85

Big Bang Shrimp

$18.85

Whipped Feta

$15.85

Gyoza Dumplings

$13.00

Soups & Salads

Beef Barley Soup

$9.65

Seasonal Soup

French Onion Soup

$11.00

Soup & Salad

$17.35

Garlic Caesar

$12.95

Fresh Greens

$12.95

Greek

$13.95

Thai Chicken

$24.35

Blackened Chicken & Goat Cheese

$24.35

Handhelds

BLACKENED BASA TACO

$21.85

California Turkey Sandwich

$23.85

Blackened Chicken on Naan

$22.65

French Dip

$23.65

Turkey & Goat Cheese on Naan

$21.85

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$21.85

Nashville Chicken Sandwich

$21.85

Burgers

The Classic

$20.85

Bacon & Cheddar

$22.85

Hell-of-a-Burger

$22.85

Garden

$23.00

Muskoka

$23.85

Bison

$27.85

Wings & Fingers

Chicken Wings

$18.85